What's New Unreplied Topics Membership About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy
[Ad]

Anyone passed an SQF Audit with No Metal Detector?

Started by , Jul 03 2018 04:17 PM
12 Replies

So... has anyone passed an initial SQF Certification audit (level 2) with multi-ingredient items (salsas, dips, hummus) without the use of a metal detector on site?   :shutup:

Share this Topic
Topics you might be interested in
BRC Metal Detection - Correct Placing of Test Pieces Pre-Assessment vs Initial Audit BRC Audit plan before the scheduled audit Risk assessment - Metal Detector vs. X Ray (foreign body detection) How many Non-conformances did you get at your last audit?
[Ad]

So... has anyone passed an initial SQF Certification audit (level 2) with multi-ingredient items (salsas, dips, hummus) without the use of a metal detector on site?   :shutup:

 

Management Commitment :thumbdown:

1 Like

Yeah, no kidding.  Naturally, I am going to push the issue - hard.  But hey, it is only my second day with the new company  :shades:

 

 

Management Commitment :thumbdown:

I would argue that Risk Analysis should dictate whether or not their is a metal detector onsite

I would argue that Risk Analysis should dictate whether or not their is a metal detector onsite

 

Best to purchase pre-Tariff ?

 

PS - Sorry Marshenko, very OT.

 

I hope someone answers yr query, does the product qualify as Low risk. sounds like RTE ?

Yes, but we had an X-Ray in it's place!

It is all RTE product, but I just had a meeting with the owner, and a metal detector will be acquired and in place when we move at the end of August.  Woot.

1 Like

Hi Marshenko,

 

Good news.

 

If only one unit may need to study the practical disposition rather carefully so as to cover all  relevant products. If only one operational packing line not a problem of course.

1 Thank

Just the one line Charles.C.  We make a couple of different density items, but only one particular category of items is run at a particular time, nothing frozen, so setup of the line for product categories should be relatively easy.

Was definitely happy to get the "oh you'll have a metal detector shortly" response immediately after posing the question.

 

 

Hi Marshenko,

 

Good news.

 

If only one unit may need to study the practical disposition rather carefully so as to cover all  relevant products. If only one operational packing line not a problem of course.

I just want to add that we do not have a metal detector onsite and also make a multi ingredient RTE product. The cutting unit (where an issue could arise) is inspected pre and post use for nicks/cracks/chips etc. We've been SQF certified for 4 years.

Update:  ain't got no metal detector, so I purchased a rare earth magnet to drop in Ye Olde Hopper as a substitute.  Management commitment indeed.

Update:  ain't got no metal detector, so I purchased a rare earth magnet to drop in Ye Olde Hopper as a substitute.  Management commitment indeed.

 

Hi Marshenko,

 

Is that cheaper or just more easily argued ? Or both ?.

 

I deduce you must have also (auditorially) adopted the Scampi (Post 10) method of physically logical observation + (the implicit)  politely forceful admonition. :smile:

Magnet was only $1000, it gets inspected after every run to check for fragments.  Equipment and hand tools are checked pre and post for any signs of breakage, and employees at the sealers are doing visual inspection of the product as best as possible.  It is the best I can do given the circumstances.

 

We may be adding more product types soon (sauces, dressings) and there will be a point where I will be insistent.

 

Hi Marshenko,

 

Is that cheaper or just more easily argued ? Or both ?.

 

I deduce you must have also (auditorially) adopted the Scampi (Post 10) method of physically logical observation + (the implicit)  politely forceful admonition. :smile:


Similar Discussion Topics
BRC Metal Detection - Correct Placing of Test Pieces Pre-Assessment vs Initial Audit BRC Audit plan before the scheduled audit Risk assessment - Metal Detector vs. X Ray (foreign body detection) How many Non-conformances did you get at your last audit? Witness Audit on an unannounced audit?! BRCGS 3.4.1 - Internal Audit frequency - To Dispute or Not to Dispute Nonconformance? Validation of Metal Detector Test Piece Sizes Costco Unannounced audit - 2023 FSSC V6 Internal audit Checklist